| 2,973 | 33 | 213 |
| 下载次数 | 被引频次 | 阅读次数 |
在数字社会中“,可供性”成为一个备受关注的学术流行语,被学者们广泛使用。但其核心内涵和特征是什么?数以百计的学术论文是否“发现”了关于可供性的新知识,推进了理论发展?本文采用系统综述的研究方法,以281篇传播学英语期刊论文为样本,通过检视技术中介传播领域中可供性的技术场景、生成过程、内容指向、社会目标和价值判断等方面,深入探讨可供性的理论化问题。研究发现,可供性是一个被多重概念化和操作化的术语,可根据技术、用户和情境的多重可变性划分为动态的三个层次。同时,可供性应被视为一个变量而非常量,在充分发挥归纳法的基础上结合演绎法和量化分析,使其作为社会现实的组织框架,搭建起勾连抽象理论和实践世界的“经验脚手架”,进一步提升其理论化程度。
Abstract:(1)Gibson,J.J.,The Ecological Approach to Visual Perception,Boston:Houghton Mifflin,1979.
(2)Norman,D.A.,The Psychology of Everyday Things,Basic Books,1988.
(3)Gaver,W.W.,"Technology affordances",in Proceedings of the SIGCHI conference,Human factors in computing systems,1991,March,pp.79-84.
(4)Wellman,B.,"Physical place and cyberplace:The rise of personalized networking",International journal of urban and regional research,vol.25,no.2,2001,pp.227-252.
(5)Hutchby,I.,"Technologies,texts and affordances".Sociology,vol 35,no.2,2001,pp.441-456.
(6)Nagy,P.,&Neff,G.,"Imagined affordance:Reconstructing a keyword for communication theory",Social Media+Society,vol.1,no.2,2015.
(7)Costa,E.,"Affordances-in-practice:An ethnographic critique of social media logic and context collapse",New media&society,vol.20,no.10,2018,pp.3641-3656.
(8)McVeigh-Schultz,J.,&Baym,N.K.,"Thinking of you:Vernacular affordance in the context of the microsocial relationship app,Couple",Social Media+Society,vol.1,no.2,2015.
(9)Faraj,S.,&Azad,B.,"The materiality of technology:An affordance perspective".In P.M.Leonardi,B.A.Nardi,&J.Kallinikos(Eds.),Materiality and Or-ganizing,Oxford:Oxford University Press,2012,pp.237-58.
(10)Evans,S.K.,Pearce,K.E.,vitak,J.,&Treem,J.W.,"Explicating affordances:A conceptual framework for understanding affordances in communication research".Journal of Computer-Mediated Communication,vol.22,no.1,2017,pp.35-52.
(11)Evans,S.K.,Pearce,K.E.,Vitak,J.,&Treem,J.W.,-Explicating affordances:A conceptual framework for understanding affordances in communication research",Journal of Computer-Mediated Communication,vol.22,no.l,2017,pp.35-52.
(12)Fromm,J.,Mirbabaie,M.,&Stieglitz,S."A Systematic Review of Empirical Affordance studies:Recommendations for Affordance Research in Information Systems".ECIS.2020.
(13)潘忠党、刘于思:《以何为“新”?“新媒体”话语中的权力陷阱与研究者的理论自省——潘忠党教授访谈录》,《新闻与传播评论》2017年第1期,第2-19页。
(14)Paul,J.,&Barari,M.,"Meta-analysis and traditional systematic literature reviews—What,why,when,where,and how?",Psychology&Marketing,vol.39,no.6,2022,pp.1099-1115.
(15)Hutchby,I.,&Barnett,S.,"Aspects of the sequential organization of mobile phone conversation discourse studies,vol.7,no.2,2005,pp.147-171.
(16)Best,K.,"Invalid command:Affordances,ICTs and user control Information",Communication&Society,vol.12,no.7,2009,pp.1015-1040.
(17)H?nska Ahy,M.,"Networked communication and the Arab Spring:Linking broadcast and social media",New Media&Society,vol.18,no.1,2016,pp.99-116.
(18)Boyd,D.,"Social network sites as networked publics:Affordances,dynamics,and Implications",In A networked self,Routledge,2010,pp.47-66.
(19)Treem,J.W.,&Leonardi,P.M.,"Social media use in organizations",Communication Yearbook,vol.36,2012,pp.143-189.
(20)Merrill,S.,&?kerlund,M.,"Standing up for Sweden?The racist discourses,architectures and affordances of an anti-immigration Facebook group Journal of Computer-Mediated Communication,vol.23,no.6,2018,pp.332-353.
(21)Maslen,S.,&Lupton,D.,"Enacting chronic illness with and through digital media:a feminist new materialist approach",Information,Communication&Society,vol.23,no.11,2020,pp.1640-1654.
(22)Manzerolle,V.,&Daubs,M.,"Friction-free authenticity:Mobile social networks and transactional affordances",Media,Culture&So,iety,vol.43,no.7,2021,pp.1279-1296.
(23)Leonardi,P.M.,"Theoretical foundations for the study of sociomateriality",Information and Organization,vol.23,no.2,2013,pp.59-76.
(24)Leonardi,P.M.,&Barley,S.R.,"Materiality and change:Challenges to building better theory about technology and organizing",Information and Organization,vol.18,no.3,2008,pp.159-176.
(25)Lee,C.K.M.,"Affordances and text-making practices in online instant messaging",Written Communication,vol.24,no.3,2007,pp.223-249.
(26)Poole,E.,Giraud,E.H.,&de Quincey,E.,"Tactical interventions in online hate speech:The case of#stopIslam",New Media&Society,vol.23,no.6,2021,pp.1415-1442.
(27)DeSanctis,G.,&Poole,M.S."Capturing the complexity in advanced technology use:Adaptive structuration theory",Organization Science,vol.5,no.2,1994,pp.121-147.
(28)Graham,T.,&Henman,P.,"Affording choice:How website designs create and constrain'choice'",Information,Communication&Society,vol.22,no.13,2019,pp,2007-2023.
(10)Xu,V.W.,"WeChat and the sharing of news in networked China",Digital Journalism,vol.10,no.9,2022,pp.1441-1463.
(30)Christensen,B.,&Khalil,A.,"Reporting conflict from afar:Journalists,social media,communication technologies,and war",Journalism Practice,vol.17,no.2,2023,pp.300-318.
(31)Pagh,J.,Zeng Skovhj,F.H.,&Lai,S.S.,"A good way to talk.A comparative analysis of communication choices in China,Denmark and the US Information",Communication&Society,vol.25,no.15,2022,pp.2317-2332.
(32)Aguirre,A.C.&Bell,A.,"Crossing the gain line:Migration,sport and national belonging on facebook",Discourse&Society,Vol.30,no.1,2019,pp.3-23.
(33)Strand,C.,"Navigating precarious visibility:Ugandan sexual minorities on Twitter",Journal of African Media Studies,vol.11,no.2,2019,pp.229-256.
(34)Costa,E.,"Affordances-in-practice:An ethnographic critique of social media logic and context collapse",New media&society,vol.20,no.10,2018,pp.3641-3656.
(35)Darling-Wolf,F.,"Virtually multicultural:Trans-Asian identity and gender in an international fan community of a Japanese star",New Media&Society,vol.6,no.4,2004,pp.507-528.
(36)Ten Oever,N.,"'This is not how we imagined it':Technological affordances,economic drivers,and the Internet architecture imaginary",New media&society,vol.23,no.2,2021,pp.344-362.
(37)Acord,S.K.,&Harley,D.,"Credit,time,and personality:The human challenges to sharing scholarly work using web 2.0",New Media&Society,vol.5,no.3,2013,pp.379-397.
(38)Are,C.,"An autoethnography of automated powerlessness:Lacking platform affordances in Instagram and TikTok account deletions",Media,Culture&Society,vol.45,no.4,2023,pp.822-840.
(39)Alexander,A.,&Aouragh,M.,"Egypt's unfinished revolution:The role of the media revisited",International Journal of Communication,vol.8,no.1,2014,pp.890-915.
(40)Sundar,S.S.,&Bellur,S.,"Concept explication in the Internet age:The case of interactivity",In E.P.Bucy&R.L.Holbert(Eds.),Sourcebook for Political Communication Research:Methods,Measures,and Analytical Techniques,New York:Routledge.2011,pp.485-500.
(41)Evans,S.K.,Pearce,K.E.,Vitak,J.,&Treem,J.W.,-Explicating affordances:A conceptual framework for understanding affordances in communication research",journal of Computer-Mediated Communication,vol.,2.no.1,2.017,pp.35-52.
(42)Gitelman,L.,Always Already New:Media,History,and the Data of Culture,MIT Press,2008.
(43)Hassenzahl,M.,&Tractinsky,N.,"User experience—a research agenda",Behavior&.Information Technology.vol.25,no.2,2006,pp.91-97.
(44)Anderson,C.A.,&Dill,K.E.,"Video games and aggressive thoughts,feelings,and behavior in the laboratory and in life,Journal of personality and social psychology,vol.78,no.4,2000,pp.772-790.
(45)Pinch,T.J.,&Bijker,W.E.,"The social construction of facts and artifacts:Or how the sociology of science and the sociology of technology might benefit each other",Social Studies of Science,vol.14,no.3,1987,pp.399-441.
(46)Koteyko,N.,van Driel,M.,&Vines,J.,"Autistic sociality on Twitter:Enacted affordances and affiliation strategies",Discourse&Communication,vol.16,no.4,2022,pp.385-402.
(47)Yeshua-Katz,D.,Shapira,&Aharonson-Daniel,L.,Clarfield,A.M.,&Sarid,O.,"Matching.digital intervention affordances with tasks:The case of a zoom and WhatsApp mental health intervention for seniors during the COVID-19 pandemic",Health Communication,vol.38,no.3,2023,pp.499-511.
(48)Bonini,T.,Treré,E.,Yu,Z.,Singh,S.,Cargnelutti,D.,&López-Ferrández,F.J.,"Cooperative affordances:How instant messaging apps afford learning,resistance and solidarity among food delivery workers",Convergence,2023.
(49)Riddick,S.,"Points of contact between activism,populism,and fandom on social media",Media and Communication,vol.10,no.4,2022,pp.191-201.
(50)Vaast,E.,&Kaganer,E.,"Social media affordances and governance in the workplace:An.examination of organizational policies",Journal of computer-mediated communication,vol.19,no.1,2013,pp.78-101.
(51)Goldberg,&Yeshua-Katz,D.,&Marciano,A.,"Online construction of romantic relationships on social media",Journal of Social and Personal Relationships,vol.39,no.6,2022,pp.1839-1862.
(52)Su,H.,"Constant connection as the media condition of love:Where bonds become bondage",Media,Culture&Society,vol.38,no.2,2016,pp.232-247.
(52)Fox,J.,Frampton,J.R.,Jones,E.,&Lookadoo,K.,"Romantic relationship dissolution on social networking sites:Selfpresentation and public accounts of breakups on Facebook",Journal of Social and Personal Relationships,vol.38,no.12,2021,pp.3732-3751.
(54)Toh,W.,&Lim,F.V.,"Using video games for learning:Developing a metalanguage for digital play",Games and Culture,vol.16,no.5,2021,pp.583-610.
(556)Berriman,L.,&Mascheroni,G.,"Exploring the affordances of smart toys and connected play in practice",New Media&Society,vol.21,no.4,2019,pp.797-814.
(56)Paulus,T.M.,&Phipps,G.,"Approaches to case analyses in synchronous and asynchronous environments",Journal of Computer-Mediated Communication,vol.13,no.2,2008,pp.459-484.
(57)Cavalcante,A.,"I Did It All Online:Transgender identity and the management of everyday life.In Queer Technologies,Routledge,2017,pp.109-122.
(58)Childs,K.M.,"'The Shade of It All':How Black Women Use Instagram and YouTube to Contest Colorism in the Beauty Industry",Social Media+Society,vol.8,no.2,2022.
(59)Vaarzon-Morel,P.,Barwick,L.,&Green,J.,"Sharing and storing digital cultural records in Central Australian Indigenous communities",New Media&Society,vol.23,no.4,2021,pp.692-714.
(60)Christensen,B.,&Khalil,A.,"Reporting conflict from afar:Journalists,social media,communication technologies,and war",Journalism Practice,vol.17,no.2,2023,pp.300-318.
(61)Barnard,S.R.,"'Tweet or be sacked':Twitter and the new elements of journalistic Practice Journalism,vol.17,no.2,2016,pp.190-207.
(62)Lou,C.,Tandoc Jr,E.C.,Hong,L.X.,Pong,X.Y.,Lye,W.X.,&Sng,N.G.,"When motivations meet affordances:News consumption on Telegram",Journalism Studies,vol.22,no.7,2021,pp.934-952.
(63)Uusitalo,N.,&Valaskivi,K.,"The attention apparatus:Conditions and affordances of news reporting in hybrid media events of terrorist violence",Journalism Practice,vol.16,no.7,2022,pp.1344-1362.
(64)Südkamp,C.M.,&Dempsey,S.E.,"Resistant transparency and nonprofit labor:Challenging precarity in the Art+Museum wage transparency campaign",Management Communication Quarterly,vol.35,no.3,2021,pp.341-367.
(65)Lane,J.,Ramirez,F.A.,&Pearce,K.E.,"Guilty by visible association:Socially mediated visibilityin gang prosecutions Journal of Computer-Mediated Communication,vol.23,no.6,2018,pp.354-369.
(66)Schwartz,B.,&Neff,G.,"The gendered affordances of Craigslist'new-in-town girls wanted'ads",New Media&Society,vol.21,no.11-12,2019,pp.2404-2421.
(67)Pearce,K.E.,&Vitak,J.,"Performing honor online:The affordances of social media for surveillance and impression management in an honor culture",New Media S Society,vol.18,no.11,2016,pp.2595-2612.
(68)Smit,R.,Heinrich,A.,&Broersma,M.,"Witnessing in the new memory ecology:Memory construction of the Syrian conflict on YouTube",New Media&Society,vol.19,no.2,2017,pp.289-307.
(69)Mills,K.A.,Scholes,L.,&Brown,A.,"Virtual reality and embodiment in multimodal meaning making",Written Communication,vol.39,no.3,2022,pp.335-369.
(70)Barrett,A.K.,Ford,J.,&Zhu,Y.,"Sending and receiving safety and risk messages in hospitals:An exploration into organizational communication channels and providers'communication overload",Health communication,vol.36,no.13,2021,pp.1697-1708.
(71)Bossio,D.,&Holton,A.E.,"Burning out and turning off:Journalists'disconnection strategies on social media",Journalism,vol.22,no.10,2021,pp.2475-2492.
(72)Chemero,A.,"An outline of a theory of affordances",Ecological Psychology,vol.15,no.2,2003,pp.181-195.
(73)Rathnayake,C.,&Winter,J.S.,"Carrying forward the uses and grats 2.0 agenda:An affordance-driven measure of social media uses and gratifications",Journal of Broadcasting&Electronic Media,vol.62,no.3,2018,pp.371-389.
(74)Davis,J.L.,How artifacts afford:The power and politics of everyday things,The MIT Press,2020.
(75)Griffin,R.,"New school speech regulation as a regulatory strategy against hate speech on social media:The case of Germany's NetzDG",Telecommunications Policy,vol.46,no.9,2022,102411.
(76)Musi,E.,&Reed,C.,"From fallacies to semi-fake news:Improving the identification of misinformation triggers across digital media",Discourse&Society,vol.33,no.3,2022,pp.349-370.
(77)孙凝翔、韩松:《“可供性”:译名之辩与范式/概念之变》,《国际新闻界》2020年第9期,第122-141页。
(78)Oliver,M.,"The problem with affordance",E-learning and digital media,vol.2,no.4,2005,pp.402-413.
(79)Zhao,S.,&Zappavigna,M.,"The interplay of(semiotic)technologies and genre:the case of the selfie",Social Semiotics,vol.28,no.5,2018,pp.665-682.
(80)Bucher,T.,&Helmond,A.,"The affordances of social media platforms",In J.Burgess,T.Poell,&A.Marwick(Eds.),The SAGE handbook of social media,Sage Publlcations,2017,pp.233-253.
(81)Pozzi,G.,Pigni,F.,&Vitari,C.,"Affordance theory in the IS discipline:A review and synthesis of the literature",In AMCIS 2014 Proceedings,2014.
(82)Bonini,T.,Treré,E.,Yu,Z.,Singh,S.,Cargnelutti,D.,&López-Ferrández,F.J.,"Cooperative af fordances:How instant messaging apps afford learning,resistance and solidarity among food delivery workers",Convergence,2023.
(83)Poole,E.,Giraud,E.H.,&de Quincey,E.,"Tactical interventions in online hate speech:The case of#stopIslam",New Media&Society,vol.23,no.6,2021,pp.1415-1442.
(84)Alacovska,A.,"The history of participatory practices:Rethinking media genres in the history of user-generated content in 19th-century travel guidebooks",Media,Culture&Society,vol.39,no.5,2017,pp.661-679.
(85)Alexander,A.,&Aouragh,M.,"Egypt's unfinished revolution:The role of the media revisited",International Journal of Communication,vol.8,no.1,2014,pp.890-915.
(86)Kavada,A.,&Treré,E.,"Live democracy and its tensions:Making sense of livestreaming in the 15M and Occupy",Information,Communication&Society,vol.23,no.12,2020,pp.1787-1804.
(87)Monroe,K.,Almond,G.,Gunnell,J.,Shapiro,I.,Graham,G.,Barber,B.,Shepsle,K.,&Cropsey,J.,"The nature of contemporary political science:A roundtable discussion",Political Science&Politics,vol.23,no,1,1990,pp.34-43.
(88)Peng,Y.,"Intellectual fads in political scieice:The cases of political socialization and community power studies",Political Science&Politics,vol.27,no.1,1994,pp.100-108.
(89)Chaffee,S.H.,Communication Concepts:Explication,Newbury Park,CA:Sage,1991.
(90)Parchoma,G.,"The contested ontology of affordances:Implications for researching technological afford dances for collaborative knowledge production",Computers in Human Behavior,vol.37,2014;pp.360-368.
(91)Oliver,M.,"The problem with affordance",E-learning and digital media,vol.2,no.4,2005,pp.402-413.
(92)Merton,R.K.,"On sociological theories of the middle range[1949]",In On Theoretical Sociology,New York:Free Press,1967,pp.39-72.
基本信息:
中图分类号:G206
引用信息:
[1]陈婧之,马烨,杜璇,等.从学术流行语到经验脚手架:对西方传播学领域“可供性”质性研究的系统综述[J].新闻与写作,2024,No.477(03):49-62.
2024-03-05
2024-03-05